I still remember November 2020. The world felt like it was unraveling, but there was this one bright spot: the PlayStation 5. I’d spent months poring over every leaked spec, every teaser trailer, every pixel of that sleek white shell. The promise? Not just a new console—but a leap. “True next-gen gaming,” they called it. Ray tracing. 120 FPS. Instant loading. A DualSense controller that could make you feel raindrops or the tension of a bowstring.
To be honest, it felt like magic was finally coming home.
And then—nothing. Or rather, nothing you could actually buy. For two long years, the PS5 wasn’t a console. It was a grail. A myth. A status symbol scalped for $1,200 on eBay while bots slurped up inventory faster than humans could click “add to cart.” At a time when millions were stuck indoors, craving escape, the PS5 became the Lambo, the Rolex, the Gucci handbag of gaming. Unattainable. Coveted. Elusive.
And that scarcity? It worked. It kept the dream alive. But it also hid something deeper—something we’re only now seeing clearly, five years later.
Because here’s the uncomfortable truth: Sony won the console war.
And yet… it somehow feels like they lost the soul of it.
What Actually Worked—And Why It Matters
Let’s not kid ourselves: the PS5 is a fantastic piece of hardware. Strip away the disappointment, the corporate missteps, the empty promises—and what’s left is genuinely impressive.
Take the SSD. Oh man, the SSD. Remember waiting 90 seconds for Red Dead Redemption 2 to load a fast travel? Or the spinning wheel of doom in Destiny 2? Gone. Vanished. On the PS5, you hit “continue,” and poof—you’re back in the action. It’s not just faster; it changes how games are designed. Developers can now build worlds without loading screens, with seamless transitions between interior and exterior spaces, with dynamic AI that doesn’t fake it during load zones. That’s not incremental—it’s revolutionary.
Then there’s the CPU. After years of the PS4’s anemic Jaguar cores bottlenecking everything, the jump to Zen 2 architecture feels like trading a tricycle for a Tesla. Suddenly, physics simulations, NPC crowds, destructible environments—things that used to be “PC-only”—are now possible on console. And 60 FPS? That’s become the new baseline, not the luxury. That alone is a generational win.
And the DualSense? Don’t let anyone tell you it’s a gimmick. The haptics in Astro’s Playroom—a free pack-in game, by the way—still give me chills. The way the triggers tense as you draw a bow in Horizon, or vibrate with the recoil of a shotgun in Returnal… it’s not just immersive. It’s emotional. It makes you care more. And yeah, Microsoft’s controller is reliable—but it’s also… safe. The DualSense dares to be different.
So yes, on paper—and in hand—the PS5 delivers. It’s balanced, powerful, and thoughtfully engineered. But here’s where things get messy.
The Library That Never Came
Remember 2021? You finally got your hands on a PS5—maybe through a raffle, maybe by camping a Best Buy website at 3 a.m.—and you rushed to play the next-gen exclusives.
Only… they weren’t next-gen. Spider-Man: Miles Morales? Also on PS4. Horizon Forbidden West? PS4. God of War: Ragnarök? Yep—PS4 again. Even Gran Turismo 7, the poster child for PS5 visuals, launched simultaneously on 2013-era hardware.
For three years, Sony’s biggest studios held back their flagship titles to support the PS4’s massive install base. And while I get it—business is business, and the pandemic wrecked development schedules—it left PS5 owners wondering: Why did I pay $500 for a slightly faster PS4?
Compare that to the PS4’s first five years: Bloodborne. Uncharted 4. The Last of Us Remastered (okay, a remaster, but still). Horizon Zero Dawn. God of War (2018). Marvel’s Spider-Man. A constant stream of bold, exclusive, generation-defining games.
The PS5’s list? Demon’s Souls (remake). Returnal. Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart. Final Fantasy XVI. Spider-Man 2. Astro Bot. Solid games—some even brilliant—but so few. And staggered so far apart that entire seasons passed with nothing new from Sony’s first-party teams.
And then there’s the elephant-shaped hole in the room: Naughty Dog. The studio behind Uncharted and The Last of Us—Sony’s crown jewel—has released zero original PS5 games. Not one. Just remasters. Their next project, Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet, won’t land until 2026 or 2027. That’s six or seven years into the PS5’s life for one game from their most celebrated team.
What happened?
The Live Service Gamble That Backfired—Hard
Around 2022, Sony made a bold (some would say reckless) pivot: they wanted to chase the “Fortnite model.” Ten to twelve live service games by 2026. Recurring revenue. Endless engagement. The dream of a gaming Netflix.
But live service games are hard. Brutally hard. And Sony wasn’t ready.
First, Naughty Dog canceled its Last of Us multiplayer project after years of development. Then Firesprite axed Twisted Metal. Insomniac shelved its Spider-Man online mode. London Studio got shut down entirely after its fantasy co-op game got canned. And then came Concord—a $40 hero shooter that sold 25,000 copies, died in two weeks, and got its studio shuttered immediately after.
One success emerged: Helldivers II. A smash hit. But one win doesn’t erase a trail of canceled projects, wasted talent, and shuttered studios. It feels less like a strategy and more like… panic. Like Sony saw Epic making billions and thought, “We can do that too!”—without realizing that live service isn’t just about tech or money. It’s about culture, community, and constant iteration. And Sony’s DNA has always been cinematic, single-player storytelling.
So while they chased the future, they neglected the present. And PS5 owners paid the price.
The $750 Question: Did Sony Forget Who They’re Serving?
Then came the PS5 Pro.
On the surface, it’s impressive. PSSR (PlayStation Spectral Super Resolution)—Sony’s AI-powered upscaling—delivers sharper images, smoother frame rates, and better ray tracing. It’s the most powerful console of this generation, no doubt.
But it costs $750—without a disc drive. Add $80 for that, and you’re at $830. For a mid-generation refresh.
Let that sink in.
The PS4 Pro launched at $400—same as the base PS4—just three years after the original. It made sense: better 4K, smoother performance, affordable upgrade. The PS5 Pro? Four years in. $750. Incremental gains that matter mostly to enthusiasts with high-end TVs.
And here’s what stings: Sony has cut production costs on every PS5 revision—smaller heat sinks, lighter power supplies, cheaper motherboards—while raising the price. They’re making record profits, but consumers see none of those savings.
This isn’t innovation. It’s extraction. And it only works because there’s no real competition.
Xbox is all-in on Game Pass and Windows. Nintendo’s doing its own thing. So Sony can charge whatever they want. And they know it.
Even the PSVR2—a legitimately stunning piece of hardware—got abandoned weeks after launch. No major support. No killer apps. Just… silence. Another expensive paperweight for early adopters.
The Ghost of PS6—and the End of Console Generations?
Just as the PS5 library is finally going full PS5-only… Sony’s already talking about the PS6. Project Amethyst. New ray tracing tech. AI upscaling. Machine learning compression.
Wait—what? I just got my PS5!
That’s the surreal part. Due to shortages and scalping, most PS5 owners have only had their consoles for 2–3 years. And now, Sony’s signaling the next generation. Meanwhile, Microsoft is abandoning the “console war” entirely, betting on Windows and Game Pass as the future.
So what’s left for Sony?
If exclusives eventually go to PC anyway…
If third-party games are on every platform…
If handhelds like the Steam Deck and ROG Ally offer more flexibility…
…then what is the PS5’s value proposition in 2025?
It’s not just a Sony problem—it’s a console problem. The old rules don’t apply. Generations used to mean clear leaps: PS3 to PS4 wasn’t just better graphics—it was a philosophical shift. But PS4 to PS5? For many, it’s just faster loading and shinier textures on the same games.
And maybe that’s okay. Maybe we’ve hit diminishing returns. Remember the first time you saw HD? It was mind-blowing. 4K? Nice, but subtle. Now we’re arguing over 4K vs. “better 4K.” At some point, the human eye stops noticing—and the human wallet starts objecting.
A Glimmer of Hope—And a Warning
I want to believe the best is yet to come. The PS3’s final years gave us The Last of Us and Uncharted 3. The PS4 ended with Ghost of Tsushima and Spider-Man. Maybe 2026–2027 will be the PS5’s golden sunset: Intergalactic, Wolverine, Stellar Blade 2, whatever Santa Monica and Insomniac have cooking.
But here’s my fear: without real competition, Sony has no reason to rush. No reason to innovate. No reason to keep prices fair or support hardware long-term.
The PS3 was a cautionary tale—too ambitious, too expensive, too isolated. Sony learned from it and built the PS4, a console that listened to players. But now, with Xbox stepping back and Nintendo in its own lane, Sony’s drifting toward complacency.
And that’s dangerous. Because the moment players feel taken for granted, they’ll go elsewhere. To PC. To cloud. To handhelds. To platforms that respect their time and money.
So… Did the PS5 Deliver?
By the numbers? Absolutely. 80+ million sold. Record profits. Market dominance. Sony won.
But by the promise? The dream of a true next-gen experience that couldn’t exist on old hardware? That redefined what games could feel like, not just look like?
I’m not so sure.
Maybe this is just the new normal: longer generations, cross-platform releases, incremental upgrades, and corporate strategies that prioritize shareholders over superfans.
But I still hold out hope. Because at its best, PlayStation isn’t just hardware—it’s heart. It’s the tear in your eye during The Last of Us. The awe in Bloodborne’s gothic labyrinth. The joy of Astro bouncing through a controller that sings in your hands.
If Sony remembers that—if they remember why we waited two years, paid $500, and kept believing—then maybe the PS5’s legacy won’t be one of missed potential… but of a slow, beautiful bloom that finally arrives just in time to say goodbye.
Until then? I’ll keep my Steam Deck charged. And my PS5 on standby—just in case magic decides to show up late.
0 Comments